|
cankles -> RE: NFL Sob (or Brag) Thread (1/10/2008 8:45:56 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: cloudboy quote:
ORIGINAL: KatyLied Getting to the playoffs in the AFC is a feat of glory. One division has 3 teams in the playoffs. I am happy with how my team played this season. I think that Ben has matured from last season. I was upset last night when people I was partying with said he "sucks" and "put in Charlie" and "he shouldn't go to the Pro Bowl", I was thinking WTF? He has a short memory and tries to get the team back in when has INT failure. Fans can be freakin idiots, can't they. Glad you had more levity. I thought PITT lost b/c it was unable to run the ball effectively against JAX. Parker was out and so was the teams LT, if I'm not mistaken. The comeback was an inspired effort, and the two-point conversion shouldn't have been nullified by that phantom holding call. ------ I know LaM has knocked Rivers, and not that I'm putting him on a pedestal, but a guy like him needs some help to succeed (as just about every QB does.) Once the line gave him time to throw, he delivered. To me its very hard to evaluate the play of a QB, because his output is so related to the rest of the offense: how the line is blocking, how the RBs keep defenses honest, and of course how the receivers play. If any of those three components breaks down, the QB usually ends up taking the blame while playing under duress. (Exhibit A. Roethelsberger in the first half throwing three Ints while the running game was disabled.) A friend of mine, taking the above into consideration, considered Peyton Manning to have the superior season to Tom Brady this year. a. Brady had his full compliment of receivers this year. Manning was minus Marvin Harrison. b. Brady's line has been healthy all year. Manning's has not. c. Bilicheck kept Brady firing away for 4 QTRS, whereas Dungy shut Manning down when games were assured. In sum, Manning's 14-2 record and performance were more impressive and valuable than Brady's considering the circumstances of their individual seasons. ------ PICKS: SEA + 9 seems like a lock over GB to me. I agree with Caitlyn, SEA pass rush dooms the Packers. Prediction: SEA wins 17-16. NE at home will soundly defeat JAX. Gerrard really can't pass well enough for them to catch up or keep up. On the other hand, there's an odd shot of JAX running the ball down NE's throat and controlling the clock. If that's the case, NE wins a squeaker. Prediction: NE wins 27-16. NYG upset Dallas. Eli Manning serves notice on Tiki Barber to shut up once and for all. Predition: NYG win 28-24. SD upsets the Colts and LT has a huge 150 yard game rushing. SD also wins the turnover battle. Norv Turner gets credit for outscheming Dungy' Cover-2 defense. SD wins 31-27. This is why it's so hard to evaluate individual efforts in football - it's the ultimate team sport, nothing happens in a vacuum. The story of the Colts this year is really extraordinary and I guess it says something about this Pats team that they were able to overshadow Indy - a team with that many injuries to important players going 14-2 is astonishing. I'm a NE fan but I have no problem admitting that Peyton has played at an MVP level these past two years. In a way I think he's kind of underrated, because of how people take his level of play for granted.
|
|
|
|