|
caitlyn -> RE: Iraq insurgents used children in car bombing (3/21/2007 10:21:02 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: dcnovice The key question, to which I honestly don't have an answer, is whether we're doing any good -- to the Iraqis, to ourselves -- by remaining there. I don't have an answer either. Lots of people are being killed in Iraq, but lots of people were already being killed. I would say that there is a chance that the killing might stop. That possibly couldn't be said if Saddam or one of his sons were in power. All speculation of course. What I like about your position in this post and the "Was Saddam a Threat" post, is that at least you are avoiding batching the mistake of going as a reason to leave. These things might be the same, but also might not. To use an analogy, some Europeans made a mistake not standing up to the Nazis when they annexed the Rhineland, but that rather huge mistake wasn't a reason to not fight the Nazis. Market Garden was a mistake which turned into a military disaster, and was undertaken for questionable objectives, but wasn't a reason to pack and go home. You certainly couldn't say, "Look, you fouled up really badly in Market Garden and had completely flawed intellience, so instead of diverting 3rd Army resources to Montgomery to take out V1 & V2 sites, we are going to keep them and let British cities be leveled. How different is Iraq, really? We probably shouldn't have gone, had questionable objectives, and very flawed intelligence ... but, does that mean we should now just pack up and go home? In my view, the answer it no. We made this mess, and are compelled to see things through. Obviously some feel differently, and thats fine. I just hope that when they link the mistake and the future, they don't let the former, cause a bad decision concerning the latter.
|
|
|
|