Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


Jeptha -> Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 10:28:37 AM)


Here's something I've been wondering about and would like to try and sort out.

It is prompted by the "Is it wrong?" thread which is going on currently. In fact, it is very like that thread, but I wanted to try and be a little more explicit and add a bit more detail.

I am thinking of this question in the context of a relationship, as opposed to casual play, although I still will use the word "play" as I can't think of a better word at the moment.

I've heard subs say that they don't want to tell their dominants what they desire, or what their fantasies are, because they don't want play (substitute whatever word you wish for "play", as appropriate) that revolves around their desires or fantasies.

They want play to revolve around whatever the dominant's desire is.

And they feel they don't want to temper, influence or dilute that.

So, the sub's desire in this case, is just a very general one,, "to serve"...without anything more specific stated.

And I think there are dominants who would concur with this view. They would probably be a good match.

Perhaps, for them, paying substantial heed to a submissive's fantasy life would be a form of catering to them, a la the 'service top'.

This subject of the submissive's fantasy life and how it is regarded has interested me for a while.

I'm curious to know how doms and subs view it.
Doms; do you want to know your sub's fantasies?
Subs; do you want to share them?

For one thing, maybe I'll have to make a further distinction in the future, for clarity's sake, if what it is that I want turns out to have an unusual slant.

And, then, I'm just nosy in general.




vasha -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 10:51:43 AM)

well of corse.  since comminicatoin is Key for a working D/s relationship,  all should be shared.  doesnt mean the Dominant would follow said fantasy, but he/she might... to some degree at least, according to his or her whimsies.




kuriouswitch -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 11:05:48 AM)

Master says he wants to know my fantasies, doesn't mean we'll do them but he likes to know what I'm thinking, what I'm focusing on or imagining at the moment. Sometimes he'll do something that involves a fantasy of mine or something similar, sometimes he'll incorporate something he enjoys with something i enjoy or sometimes it's just focused on his pleasure. It really just depends on his mood, if I've pleased him well lately and time contraints. But the rule is, even if it doesn't happen I have to tell him, and usually it might not happen that night or for a while but he does eventually allow it to, usually when I think he's forgotten about it lol.




SteelofUtah -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 11:13:27 AM)

I stayed out of the other conversation because I came in too late and didn't want to derail things too far.

This however is more on line with what I ultimatly get frustrated with when I get asked my opinion on it in other forums.

We all know the Mind Reading Rant, so I'll spare you the type. However more than anything this is what that is.

GUESS WHAT! I was Under the impression that this was about MUTUAL needs being met. Should a sub not get reciproication on the "Feel Goods"?

When andi asks for something she is telling me something and usually not just that she wants a certain act done she is also telling me that she is NOT getting something that she feels is important enough to ask me about.

When someone is so caught up in the CONCEPT of the Dynamic that they feel they can't ask "Hey, I kinda wanna know what it feels like to hit with a two by four and fisted by an oranatang." and the reason is that they don't want their play to revolve around what they want, I react with a look like somoene just took off their own head.

If a sub has such little faith in the their Dom that they feel they cant ask for something without it all being about them and the Dom just filling a request their is something wrong. When andi asks me for something I decide if I even want to engage in that act if I do then We do, it isn't what she wants it's what I want having addressed that her desire was important to me.

I don't jump to and start swinging because she wants me to, I am the one in control in the relationship and even if I do jump up and go at it, it has nothing to do with it revolving around her desires it is because I thought that was a good idea and I wanted it too after bening presented with the idea.

By the other way of thinking when the girl says "Hot Day, Ice Cream would be nice today." and I drive us to Baskin Robins I just became subservient? No I was just hot and Ice Cream sounded good so we went.

Steel




leadership527 -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 11:37:36 AM)

Yes, What Steel said.

Maybe I'm a service dom, but yeah, I derive a great deal of pleasure out of pleasing Carol... sexually and in any number of other ways. I fail to see how deliberately engineering my marriage so that Carol receives a lot of joy from it in any way connects to "who's in charge." I love the woman. Her joy is mine.




Prinsexx -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 11:55:12 AM)

If the dom doesn't turn out to BE my fantasy I will just go and fantasize about someone else.
Not a good thing in the long run........
water will always find its level.




RCdc -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 12:06:23 PM)

Master instructs I tell him everything and that includes any fantasy.  I would be disobedient if I was to withold such information and making that decision for him by not telling him.  It is his desire to be told and I submit to his desire.  If I did not wish to share then I would not be in a relationship with Darcy as Master was explicit in his expectations and requirements from the start.  Master does not do fake nor pretense.
 
the.dark.




BandS -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 12:12:03 PM)

I believe it is very important to know the sub's fantasies, just like I believe it is important to know what she, or he, is thinking and feeling.  As I see it, being dominant isn't simply about getting what I want all of the time, it is about guiding our lives to be the best they can possibly be.  There are times we focus on my needs and times we focus on S's.  Knowing what she fantasizes about doesn't obligate me to fulfill those fantasies, but it does color some of our interactions.  Even though I tell her my fantasies, we might not explore them soon if at all, but the sharing brings us closer.




IrishMist -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 12:24:12 PM)

What about those of us who don't have, and have never had; fantasies about anything in relation to relationships?

It does happen you know.




dreamofthemoon -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 12:28:27 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SteelofUtah

...

I don't jump to and start swinging because she wants me to, I am the one in control in the relationship and even if I do jump up and go at it, it has nothing to do with it revolving around her desires it is because I thought that was a good idea and I wanted it too after bening presented with the idea.

By the other way of thinking when the girl says "Hot Day, Ice Cream would be nice today." and I drive us to Baskin Robins I just became subservient? No I was just hot and Ice Cream sounded good so we went.

Steel

Hello, all,

i know i don't post a ton in this forum (gee, quelle surprise! [8|]), but after reading through, i happen to agree with Steel. Sometimes it's just as simple as you both wanted ice cream. [:D]




RCdc -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 12:46:25 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: IrishMist

What about those of us who don't have, and have never had; fantasies about anything in relation to relationships?

It does happen you know.


Depends what you mean by a fantasy though IM.
For me, a fantasy is always something fulfillable and can be a dream.  Even an aspiration sometimes.  It's a desire.  It's not just about being tied to lamp post in Tunisia or something like that.
 
So for example, on another thread, you said that violence is sexy.  To me, that is a fantasy too.  But of course, it does depend how one interprets the word 'fantasy'.
 
the.dark.




SteelofUtah -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 12:52:43 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: IrishMist

What about those of us who don't have, and have never had; fantasies about anything in relation to relationships?

It does happen you know.


Those of you who do not have and never have had fantasies....... this thread doesn't apply to.

However I find it difficult to believe that you don't have them. I fantasize about kissing my wife when I get home....... so when I get home I kiss her.

Fantasies don't have to be drawn out and fantastic they just have to be something you go to mentally before expressing physically.

Steel




CreativeDominant -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 12:59:25 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeptha


Here's something I've been wondering about and would like to try and sort out.

It is prompted by the "Is it wrong?" thread which is going on currently. In fact, it is very like that thread, but I wanted to try and be a little more explicit and add a bit more detail.

I am thinking of this question in the context of a relationship, as opposed to casual play, although I still will use the word "play" as I can't think of a better word at the moment.

I've heard subs say that they don't want to tell their dominants what they desire, or what their fantasies are, because they don't want play (substitute whatever word you wish for "play", as appropriate) that revolves around their desires or fantasies.

They want play to revolve around whatever the dominant's desire is.

And they feel they don't want to temper, influence or dilute that.

So, the sub's desire in this case, is just a very general one,, "to serve"...without anything more specific stated.

And I think there are dominants who would concur with this view. They would probably be a good match.

Perhaps, for them, paying substantial heed to a submissive's fantasy life would be a form of catering to them, a la the 'service top'.

This subject of the submissive's fantasy life and how it is regarded has interested me for a while.

I'm curious to know how doms and subs view it.
Doms; do you want to know your sub's fantasies?
Subs; do you want to share them?

For one thing, maybe I'll have to make a further distinction in the future, for clarity's sake, if what it is that I want turns out to have an unusual slant.

And, then, I'm just nosy in general.

Good question and, if it matters, I don't see it as being all that similar.  The question that was asked was whether or not it was wrong for the submissive to ask her dominant for something she wants/needs/desires.  Here, I see the question as being for the two partners in the dynamic and concerning whether or not the question even gets heard, not whether it is wrong to ask it.

1st Question:  Dominants, do you want to know your submissive's fantasies?

In a word, yes.

As Steel noted, it HAS been said a million times but it seems to bear repetition---no dominant is a mindreader.  I had a discussion along similar though slightly different lines recently.  More specifically, it was about whether or not the dominant should inquire as to what the submissive wants sexually.  On one hand, if all he wants that information for is so that he can always do what she wants, then I could see the point of the submissive I was speaking with---a dominant behaving can lead himself and the submissive into a situation in which the submissive feels like the dominant is 1.)  a service top  2.)  lacking in his own creativity and desires or unable/unsure how to express them. 
On the other hand, a submissive who just expects the dominant to do what he wants to do sexually...without making clear to him what she WON'T, or doesn't WANT to do sexually...is in fact giving "carte blanche" to the dominant to do just that.  So, the dominant goes ahead and does want he wants to do sexually, feeling lucky that he gets to "be in charge" and have his wants and needs come foremost and, hopefully, address some of her fantasies.  Then boom...he does something that she does NOT want to have happen.  Now, if the submissive realizes that this is partially due to her own expectation of the dominant to somehow "know" and "lead" and "take charge" and is willing to step back with the dominant and discuss and get it back on the right track, great.   But if she wants to get angry because he even tried it and pull back from him without discussion or even a statement to let him know what he did wrong, then that isn't right anymore than it is right for him to get angry if she tries to stop the "unwanted" sexual and/or BDSM act and discuss this unforeseen occurrence.  Prior discussion of things helps and, since not all possible outcomes of play can be covered, understanding and patience when something unforeseen and unplanned but unwanted happens goes a long way.

To touch on fantasies specifically, I've discussed this with this same submissive...and others.  Again, the mind-reader thing comes into play but another aspect comes into play also...and that is the idea of taking care of your property---if looking at this from a strictly D/s standpoint---and the idea of taking care of your partner---if also coming at this from the relationship standpoint.  I come at it from both.  To take care of my partner, I have to recognize that while serving my needs and catering to my wants and desires is always important to her, it is important for the health of her overall make-up (mental, emotional, physical) to have what she likes/wants/needs/desires addressed on occasion.  And you know what?  In my world, she needs to recognize the importance and the right of having her wants and needs and desires met. 
Now then, the idea that just the act of stating the submissive's wants/needs/desires---for those of us from the other thread, no matter HOW she states it---somehow correlates to "she expects it to happen right away is a misconception.  If she does, then in my dynamic there would be a problem.  I would think though that most submissives understand that once she has stated this, it is then up to the dominant as to how and when those wants and desires are met.  But I still believe that the dominant who takes forever to address what she has asked has 1.)  stilted her desire to communicate other things as well for he has at least given an indication of the importance of what she wants/needs/desires from the sexual/BDSM arena to him and 2.) taken a big step towards being on his own again someday.
Another aspect comes into play and it doesn't necessarily have a sexual component.  I want my submissive to trust me enough, to feel safe enough with me to delve into the darker areas of her soul and mind...the painful areas (if need be)...the mundane but important areas...with me.  One way to build that trust is for her to be able to share her fantasies with me and see that I don't dismiss them in any fashion.
Finally...from a sexual perspective.  While many submissives are indeed sexual creatures and "appropriately slutty" in their behavior, making them share their fantasies creates not only an arena of trust (as discussed above) but also creates an arena for a bit of good old-fashioned sexual humiliation (perhaps the reason she doesn't share quite so readily is not because she doesn't want to but rather, she is embarrassed to do so verbally) because of having to relate in words what she loves to show you she likes...perhaps would rather show you than have to tell you.




IronBear -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 1:22:52 PM)

I like this question Jeptha, you and I oft appear to see many things in a similar manner. Given time I expect any slave in either my personal or the Bruin Cottage Collar to fess up his or her fantasies. I am indeed interested in them and am more than happy to perhaps incorperate them in some form of play or another. As a therapist, I find fantasies most helpful in helping my client/patient in some problem areas. 




Prinsexx -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 1:55:10 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: IronBear
As a therapist, I find fantasies most helpful in helping my client/patient in some problem areas. 

This I also agree with. Enabling a client to be creative about with their fantasies is a valuable way of enabling a client to move on from a 'stuckness'.
Working with others and gaining their trust is an amazing experience.
It has been freeing for me as a person.
I used to have repetitive and almost obsessive fantasies.When I was first out as as submissive I found it very difficult to confess. I used to think it upset the dynamic. But confessing never does, simply because it is a confession and not a demand and the dominant reserves the right to act on the fantasy or not. But gradually with the help of different play partners and in relationships I have confessed most of them. Thus I have few fantasies left that I have not been lucky enough to have fulfilled.
Of course they are not just situational but person dependent and a new relationship equals new potentials and new horizons.
What is interesting though ae those fantasies that remain fantasies and will never be acted upon. i think we all have those. And enabling clients to feel that it is ok to explore the taboo within their heads is ok too.





lizi -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 2:24:57 PM)

I have preferences rather than fantasies. My Dom wants to know my preferences and I share them with him. He asks me for this information and he chooses to use it...or not. I don't think it makes him any weaker to do what I like because in fact that's exactly what he gets off on. It may seem like our play is revolving around me but I don't believe that to be true - he's in control and he's making the choices.

In the end my positive reaction is a springboard for him to enjoy what he's doing even more. I am serving him by allowing him to know what makes me an individual and what gets me going- it's like handing someone the keys to a car and letting them take it for a drive. He's not catering to me, he's taking the car that belongs to him out for a drive whenever he feels like it.




Domitianus -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 2:28:27 PM)

It is always a good thing to know a sub's fantasies and desires. For one, it can make a nice reward if she has served well. More generally, it may spark other ideas or tangents on which to embarque. Grist for the mill.




Leonidas -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 2:31:56 PM)

As a slave owner (enough like a dom for the purposes of this discussion, I guess) my expectation is that the slave's fantasy life belongs to me, along with the rest of her.  If I am interested in examining it, I'd expect her to offer it up just as quickly as she spreads her thighs and offers up the other end on command.

Why might I like to examine it?  It is another form of stripping her naked, and reminding her that she is fact a slave in my house for one thing.  It may also give me some insight into how to go about eliciting responses from her that I find pretty or enjoyable.  Whether she would prefer to withhold those responses for the sake of modesty or dignity or some misguided sense of being served isn't of particular concern.  She is a slave afterall.

Seems pretty straightforward to me.




NyDaddysGirl -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 3:24:43 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeptha

I've heard subs say that they don't want to tell their dominants what they desire, or what their fantasies are, because they don't want play (substitute whatever word you wish for "play", as appropriate) that revolves around their desires or fantasies.



In addition to the points made previously about communication being important and no one being mind readers, there is one other thing that really stands out to me.  When I read the first sentence in the portion that I quoted and omit the reason, it translates (to me) as:  "I don't want to".  (Imho, the reason just translates as an excuse.)  Unless I've been told specifically that my desires/fantasies are of no interest, it's my opinion that it would be disrespectful to not share that part of me.

Ultimately, by sharing those things, I am providing my Daddy with information that he can then use to his benefit (eliciting specific responses during play, etc.) as well as the possibility that there might be an opportunity for me to experience one or more of my fantasies, should he decide to act on one or more of them.  It also provides him with deeper insight as to what makes me tick and how I think, etc.  It puts him deeper in my head.

Note:  I have a cold and took meds for it, so if I didn't make sense or pissed anyone off, my apologies.




sweetsub1957 -> RE: Regarding Submissive's Fantasies... (7/16/2009 3:44:32 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Jeptha

This subject of the submissive's fantasy life and how it is regarded has interested me for a while.

I'm curious to know how doms and subs view it.
Doms; do you want to know your sub's fantasies?
Subs; do you want to share them?



Sir does want to know about my fantasies and preferences, and consequently I do want to share them.  Sometimes, though, I get really embarrassed when trying to.....I get embarrassed rather easily and am shy about some things, like sharing my fantasies.  lol  But just because I share them, it doesn't mean He has to incorporate them into play.  He can if He wants to & we both understand that He still has full control, no matter what.  I trust Him completely.  [:D]




Page: [1] 2 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.125