Earth and Oil (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


FangsNfeet -> Earth and Oil (5/26/2008 10:24:32 PM)

Earth has oil in it for a reason does it not? All that decayed matter is down under the crust to later become something else. I wonder what it's real purpose is. As we continue to use and end up deleting oil, what part of the puzzle are we taking out of Earths big picture in evolution and change.




cyberdude611 -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/26/2008 11:27:30 PM)

Nothing...

There is nothing we can do to this planet that the planet cant and wont fix. If we use it all up....several million years from now, oil will be replenished.

Humans have the power to wipe out their own existance. But we do not have the power to destroy the planet or kill every life on earth.

If we disappear tomorrow....the earth will go on...and so will life.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 12:01:52 AM)

quote:

Nothing...

There is nothing we can do to this planet that the planet cant and wont fix. If we use it all up....several million years from now, oil will be replenished.

Humans have the power to wipe out their own existance. But we do not have the power to destroy the planet or kill every life on earth.

If we disappear tomorrow....the earth will go on...and so will life.


I hear that assertion all the time, and I don't get it.  The Earth as a rock revolving around the Sun will go on most definitely until the Sun or some other outside force destroys it.  However, life can be extinguished.  It's entirely possible that man could completely wipe out all life on Earth.  It is completely reasonable to imagine us turning the Earth into Venus, where no life exists.  We don't know if we can do it, but it's possible. 

But even if it isn't possible to wipe out life completely, what kind of argument is that?  Is is okay to destroy our own species just because the cockroaches will live? 




Hippiekinkster -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 12:11:38 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

quote:

Nothing...

There is nothing we can do to this planet that the planet cant and wont fix. If we use it all up....several million years from now, oil will be replenished.

Humans have the power to wipe out their own existance. But we do not have the power to destroy the planet or kill every life on earth.

If we disappear tomorrow....the earth will go on...and so will life.


I hear that assertion all the time, and I don't get it.  The Earth as a rock revolving around the Sun will go on most definitely until the Sun or some other outside force destroys it.  However, life can be extinguished.  It's entirely possible that man could completely wipe out all life on Earth.  It is completely reasonable to imagine us turning the Earth into Venus, where no life exists.  We don't know if we can do it, but it's possible. 

But even if it isn't possible to wipe out life completely, what kind of argument is that?  Is is okay to destroy our own species just because the cockroaches will live? 

I read, and I cannot find a citation with my limited data-mining abilities, so this must be considered "hearsay", that a plant pathogen, lab-created, which is toxic to ALL plant life, nearly escaped the lab.

Ruh-Roh.

It's absolutely possible that humans could wipe out all life on Earth.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 12:27:05 AM)

quote:

I read, and I cannot find a citation with my limited data-mining abilities, so this must be considered "hearsay", that a plant pathogen, lab-created, which is toxic to ALL plant life, nearly escaped the lab.

Ruh-Roh.

It's absolutely possible that humans could wipe out all life on Earth.


Wow Hippie, you and I have finally found something we agree on.  *shakes hands with Hippie and now knows that world peace is possible* 

I have never understood that argument that humans are incapable of wiping out life.  We've been industrialized for 150 years.  In that time period, we have managed to cause a lot of damage.  We have wiped out entire species.  We have made entire areas of the Earth uninhabitable.  We figured out how to manipulate the atom 60 years ago and wipe out all of humanity with that discovery.  Who knows what we are going to come up with in the 21st Century.  I am a pessimist when it comes to humanity.  I think we are going to continue finding all sorts of ways to kill ourselves. 





Hippiekinkster -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 1:19:01 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

quote:

I read, and I cannot find a citation with my limited data-mining abilities, so this must be considered "hearsay", that a plant pathogen, lab-created, which is toxic to ALL plant life, nearly escaped the lab.

Ruh-Roh.

It's absolutely possible that humans could wipe out all life on Earth.


Wow Hippie, you and I have finally found something we agree on.  *shakes hands with Hippie and now knows that world peace is possible* 

I have never understood that argument that humans are incapable of wiping out life.  We've been industrialized for 150 years.  In that time period, we have managed to cause a lot of damage.  We have wiped out entire species.  We have made entire areas of the Earth uninhabitable.  We figured out how to manipulate the atom 60 years ago and wipe out all of humanity with that discovery.  Who knows what we are going to come up with in the 21st Century.  I am a pessimist when it comes to humanity.  I think we are going to continue finding all sorts of ways to kill ourselves. 



Baby steps. [8D]

Look up when atomic energy was discovered. Then look up when LSD was discovered. Hmmmm... maybe some kind of karmic balance here, no? Interesting stuff. John Beresford-amazing dude.
http://www.hofmann.org/lsd/index.html




cyberdude611 -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 9:08:28 AM)

The asteroid impact that wiped out the dinosaurs caused a massive dust cloud that blocked the sun from the earth's surface for decades. More than 90% of all life was destroyed. Entire ecosystems were destroyed. Most land life became extinct.

Humans almost went extinct 60,000 years ago. The Supervolcano under Lake Toba in Indonesia erupted which scientists believed reduced the human species to a population of mere 1,000s. Yellowstone, a much more powerful Supervolcano, is due to erupt any time. When that happends, the entire earth will go into nuclear winter. Yellowstone erupts like clockwork every 600,000 years. The earth is used to it.

These events are nothing new. These cycles of Earth hitting the "reset" button has happend hundreds of times in the history of this planet. Everytime the Earth finds a way to restart the ecosystem and evolution will continue. Cockroaches can survive nuclear blasts. Life can survive in the soil. And dont forget life on the ocean floor. Thousands of feet below the surface of the water in pitch blackness, life lives without any sunlight at all....many species we have yet to even discover.

Also remember that we have fossils of tropical plants found in Alaska and Siberia. Meaning about 50 million years ago...there were rain forests up there. At one point, this planet was much hotter than it is today.

The Earth will not turn into Venus. Venus is too close to the sun which is why it is burning up, and Mars is too far away from the sun, which is why the water is frozen at its ice caps. The Earth is at that perfect distance for life.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ozO4YB98mCY




DomKen -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 9:53:52 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: cyberdude611
Also remember that we have fossils of tropical plants found in Alaska and Siberia. Meaning about 50 million years ago...there were rain forests up there. At one point, this planet was much hotter than it is today.

Never heard of continental drift I guess.

quote:

The Earth will not turn into Venus. Venus is too close to the sun which is why it is burning up, and Mars is too far away from the sun, which is why the water is frozen at its ice caps. The Earth is at that perfect distance for life.

Atmospheric physics and chemsitry eluded you too I see. In reality Venus is much much hotter than it would be if not for the mix of gases in its atmosphere. Various clues suggest that Earth's atmosphere was essentially Venusian when life was getting started. Mars is cold not just because it is farther away from the sun. The planet's low surface gravity results ina thin atmosphere not capable of trapping much heat.




pettingdragons -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 11:04:50 AM)

as my sweet little niece put it....."if we take out the oil will we all fall in the wholes?"

[:)]


pettingdragons
**Master Dragons considered slave**




BBWnNC72 -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 11:07:07 AM)

Humans are the only  species that if we were to all die off, things would get better.  Any other species dies and it affects something down the line.




cyberdude611 -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 11:13:07 AM)

And I suppose you buy into the junk science that if we keep driving our cars the way we are that our atmosphere is going to end up like Venus?

The eruption of Mt Saint Helens spewed more greenhouse gases into the atmosphere in that single eruption than all the cars on the planet combined in a 10 year period.

Our contribution of greenhouses gases to the atmosphere is minuscule.

And we are NOT running out of oil! Jesus Christ....There is enough oil another 150-200 years at least! Our technology is also increasing meaning we can drill deeper and we are finding oil all over the place. They just recently found a new source of oil in Brazil. There is 1.2 trillion barrels in the Canadian oil sands. There is a ton of oil under Venezuela that hasnt even been touched yet. There is a ton of oil under the Gulf of Mexico and in Alaska. There is a ton in Siberia that still hasnt been tapped. There oil sources on the ocean floor of the Arctic Sea off the coast of Norway. The US is in West Africa right now signing oil deals. And I havnt even started on the oil shale and coal yet... We got coal up the wahzoo in the United States.

We are not running out of energy! Where are these lies coming from???




Irishknight -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 11:32:50 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomKen


Never heard of continental drift I guess.




The continents no longer drift without the oil to lubricate them.




DomKen -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 11:39:44 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: cyberdude611

And I suppose you buy into the junk science that if we keep driving our cars the way we are that our atmosphere is going to end up like Venus?

The eruption of Mt Saint Helens spewed more greenhouse gases into the atmosphere in that single eruption than all the cars on the planet combined in a 10 year period.

Source please? Limbaugh doesn't count.

quote:

Our contribution of greenhouses gases to the atmosphere is minuscule.

In 1750 CO2 was at 275 ppm now its at 384 ppm. A 40% increase doesn't strike as miniscule.

quote:

And we are NOT running out of oil! Jesus Christ....There is enough oil another 150-200 years at least! Our technology is also increasing meaning we can drill deeper and we are finding oil all over the place. They just recently found a new source of oil in Brazil. There is 1.2 trillion barrels in the Canadian oil sands. There is a ton of oil under Venezuela that hasnt even been touched yet. There is a ton of oil under the Gulf of Mexico and in Alaska. There is a ton in Siberia that still hasnt been tapped. There oil sources on the ocean floor of the Arctic Sea off the coast of Norway. The US is in West Africa right now signing oil deals. And I havnt even started on the oil shale and coal yet... We got coal up the wahzoo in the United States.

First of all unless you're claiming oil is in infinite supply we are definitely running out. the question always has been when will the tank run dry not whether it will.

Second a lot of the oil you're claiming is usable is not economically viable to produce. Oil sand for instance isn't economically viable at less than a couple of hundred a barrel.

quote:

We are not running out of energy! Where are these lies coming from???

You tell us since you're the one telling them.




FangsNfeet -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 8:50:47 PM)

Look everyone, I'm just curious as to what Nature has instored for oil on a geology stand point.

Just how possible is it that oil may play a part in plate techtonics, earthquakes, the earths core, and the future formation of land scape.

What would be the next step for oil to play should it go untouched for another few million or billion years?

Most oil finds/strikes burst out of the earth from extreme pressure from drilling. The continuous draing of oil and release of pressure under the earths crust causes me to think how this action might be altering future geological paterns and movement within the earth.

So what's natures reason for having oil?




slaveboyforyou -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 9:10:29 PM)

quote:

Just how possible is it that oil may play a part in plate techtonics, earthquakes, the earths core, and the future formation of land scape.


Oil does not cause earthquakes or effect plate tectonics.  Oil is not at the Earth's core, which consists primarily of iron.  The only effect it has on landscape is the alterations we cause by drilling for it. 




Alumbrado -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 9:14:54 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: FangsNfeet

Look everyone, I'm just curious as to what Nature has instored for oil on a geology stand point.

Just how possible is it that oil may play a part in plate techtonics, earthquakes, the earths core, and the future formation of land scape.

What would be the next step for oil to play should it go untouched for another few million or billion years?

Most oil finds/strikes burst out of the earth from extreme pressure from drilling. The continuous draing of oil and release of pressure under the earths crust causes me to think how this action might be altering future geological paterns and movement within the earth.

So what's natures reason for having oil?
 

Good questions, and I certainly don't know, but I do know a most excellent geologist...I'll ask her when next I see her.




FangsNfeet -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 9:18:40 PM)

But what about in another billion years? Over time, the oil under the crust is bound to change and is meant to play some part in future development and landscaping.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 9:24:18 PM)

Over time, oil seeps up through the ground naturally and evaporates.  It's not meant to do anything.  It's just organic matter that has been subjected to pressure and heat.  It's essentially biological garbage. 




Hippiekinkster -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 10:04:35 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

Over time, oil seeps up through the ground naturally and evaporates.  It's not meant to do anything.  It's just organic matter that has been subjected to pressure and heat.  It's essentially biological garbage. 
Eseentially. Doesn't seep in many places, though. There's generally substantial pressure (called "overburden") capping the oil-bearing strata.




Termyn8or -> RE: Earth and Oil (5/27/2008 11:07:36 PM)

Hold on here.

You have all heard of underground aquifers and streams. They exist all over the planet. Some underground streams might do wonders for the tree in front of your house, but others may erode the underneath of the ground and well can cause the collapse of your house. It would not be the first time.

Now see the bigger picture and see that we have pumped a sea of oil out of the ground already. How many barrels a day ? Do the math.

Physical laws state that a liquid cannot be compressed, as such that oil was supporting something. I wonder if anyone bothered to check the elevation over the years.

And I think someone mentioned all the other things oil is used for, part of it is making plastic, there are also numerous chemicals the drug industry buys, and a few other things. Gasoline is not the last word, but what of all these other things ?

Hemp. It can't replace all of it but it would help. Thing is, alot of times a petrol prodict is used with something else already. Many plastics are a simple mix of petrol based solvents and cellulose, although those see alot less use now in light of much better alternatives.

When asked why pot was illegal I said "Because of the oil companies" and I drew some attention.

Hemp can be put into a threshing type machine to make the fibers, whether combined with modified hemp oil or a petro product, it can become a viable plastic.

In fact it may be superior in longevity, giving big money yet another impetus to keep it off the table.

The fact is nothing changes until we change, and right now nobody hardly knows what that means. If you were to boycott gas right now, and ride a bicycle everywhere, it would not accomplish anything. Even if you ride to the store every day to buy food, all of it, it still got there by means of oil.

Ride out to the mall and pickup a new iPod, it technically took more in oil to make it than it would to drive there, unless you rode a really long time.

But there are things about oil. Touching upon the middle east real quick, Kuwait had heavy crude while Iraq had light sweet crude. This is why the Kuwaitis crossdrilled across the border, stealing Iraqi oil for years.

The light sweet yields more gasoline and aromatics and is very easy to crack. The heavy crude yields less gas and whatever and a good portion of it becomes linoleun. It is not worth a hundred and change per barrel to say the least, it does not trade the same.

What's more heavy crude has a higher viscosity which can make it harder to pump out of the ground. It is also harder to force through any pipeline, so when that light sweet is going for over a hundred bucks a barrel, this other stuff ain't. It is that simple.

However that does not mean it is useless. Actually China's desire for oil is not so much for gas, what do you think a billion people all bought Hummers all the sudden ? No, everything they make has plastic in it, and it takes oil to make plastic. Their exports depend on plastic, and plastic depends on oil. They are probably buying the Kuwaiti stuff for that purpose. But not at no $130 a barrell.

And the main reason it does not trade at the quoted price is that it takes more energy to crack it. As much as they have refined the process over the years, some of it cracks easier.

And long term ? We have pumped a sea of oil out of the ground, almost literally from under our own feet. From deserts, and perhaps that is OK. Maybe with the oil gone the elevation will go down resulting in flooding. And if you know anything, you know that flooding in of seawaters is exactly what makes land fertile, or ready to become fertile.

Sometimes I think nature will correct any challenge we present, and in fact we are part of nature. Unless you were not born on this planet, what you do is part of nature.

What our ultimate effect on the environment is, not clear. Probably not good overall, but I say this, we have every right to do it, but then we don't.

Got kids ? Want to destroy their future environment ? Of course not. But we do have an effect on this planet just by being here and we need not feel guilty about it or anything. Just see it for what it is.

Or we can go chicken little, Al Gore, the sky is falling because we heated up the planet by 0.00000000002%, it'll be the end of things ! NO NO DON'T LIGHT THAT CIGARETTE, you might tip the delicate balance and cause armegeddon.

Yup, right, put your arms in here. And we got a room for you, padded walls, you'll love it.

T




Page: [1] 2   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
3.222656E-02