Judging others...

Judging others... (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion

Message

emdoub -> Judging others... (11/13/2006 11:00:58 PM)
This came up in another thread, but rather than contribute further to the topic drift, I brought it here. Things were calming down, but this stuck in my craw - I couldn't let it go by unremarked. Hmmm... I don't want to quote someone outside of the thread they posted to without permission, and it really doesn't matter who said it - it's been said by lots of people in lots of places. Apologies to the author if they'd have preferred the attribution. quote: ORIGINAL: Nunya Bidness this is why i try not to have "opinions" about anyone personally; they are really judgements on ones character in the end. Oh, how did 'judgemental' get to be a bad word, and an awful thing to do to someone? If someone can't make judgements about me, how can they decide that I'm wonderful, or not their type, or a flaming asshole? I use judgements all the time about people. This person, I judge to be distasteful to me and unsafe socially - they're not welcome in my house. That person, I judge to be a kindred soul, so we have lunch every week, just to have an afternoon of "us, surrounded by them". Another, I judge to be goodhearted, but self-destructive - so while I wish them the best, and like them just fine, I've gotta distance myself, so as to be elsewhere when they go >splat<. Simply put, I have no idea of how I'd live my life without making judgements, and trusting my judgement, and accepting the consequences when I make a mistake in my judgements. If someone is not allowed to judge people, how can they decide between me and some other HNG to be their next try at a d/s relationship? Without judgement, it'd have to be on a first come, first served basis. (In which case, I wanna be first, eh? But I'd prefer to be served before I come.) Many people have attempted to insult me by calling me judgemental. I tend to surprise them by thanking them - I'm glad that it shows when I have judgement, and use it. I'd hate to be thought of as having no judgement, after all. Midnight Pontificator

Lordandmaster -> RE: Judging others... (11/13/2006 11:08:14 PM)
To me, the difference between judging and being judgmental is making a good-faith effort to put yourself in the other person's shoes before coming to a verdict. I agree with you that it's hardly possible to live without making judgments, including judgments about other people, but what I find is that too often people make hasty judgments based merely on their own habits and unreflective preferences. I'd call THAT judgmental.

SirGordonslil -> RE: Judging others... (11/13/2006 11:09:37 PM)
[:D][:)]here! here! emdoub, well put[:)][:D] without judgment i wouldnt have the good friends i have today.

diamonddreamlove -> RE: Judging others... (11/13/2006 11:10:17 PM)
I use my judgement but try not to be judgemental which implies being critical of another.

Kalira -> RE: Judging others... (11/13/2006 11:11:08 PM)
I think that the word 'judgement' gets a bad reputation because many associate it with the negative. For myself, and myself only, if I judge someone it usually means that they are coming up short in my OWN opinions and expectations of them. ( notice how I said my own ) I judge and one of two things follows; I either condemn, or I accept.

LuckyAlbatross -> RE: Judging others... (11/13/2006 11:14:14 PM)
http://www.collarchat.com/m_580951/mpage_1/key_judgmental/tm.htm#580987 Judgmental http://www.collarchat.com/m_643238/mpage_1/key_judgmental/tm.htm#643252 What do you think?

emdoub -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 12:00:23 AM)
Lordandmaster - what you call judgemental', I call 'poor judgement'. Poor judgement is one of those things about which I am, indeed, very judgemental, in a very negative way. Thanks, SirGordonslil! diamonddreamlove - you and Kalira seem to be on the same page, so I'll answer you both together. quote: ORIGINAL: Kalira I think that the word 'judgement' gets a bad reputation because many associate it with the negative. Positive judgements are impossible without negative judgements. Nor should we fear negative judgements. These have kept me from inviting a thief back into my home, kept my daughter from associating with a charming, personable guy who has the nasty habit of inciting fights among his friends, and prevents me from befriending social homophobes. (I should probably explain that term. If someone simply gets the willies about GLBT folks, and politely maintains a distance, keeping their problem to themselves, fine - that's polite behavior, and all I can ask. A social homophobe makes their attitude about GLBT folks clear, and expects it to be socially acceptable. In my society, it ain't.) Yes, it would probably be a wonderful world if there were not people whom I judged 'unworthy'. Unfortunately, I don't live there - I live here, where there are plenty of people who are not worth my time or energy, much less my society or friendship. The funny thing that was pointed out in one of the threads LuckyAlbatross pointed toward is that the folks who whine about someone being 'judgemental' are doing so as an act of judgement. [8\|] Maybe I should add "judgemental asshole" to my profile - truth in advertising, after all. Midnight Writer

leatherzack -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 1:40:55 AM)
For me, there is a big difference between having an opinion on someone's behavior and judging that person. The term "judging" is more definite to me. And to really judge someone, i think you have to know a lot about that person first, not just assume things (which is rather easy).

eyesopened -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 3:23:01 AM)
The definintion of Discernment (which no one would think of as an negative) is to "show insight and judgement" By definition judgement and discerment are the same. Some folks will stand on semantics and i declare myself Anti-Semantic. As one who wrote advertising copy for a living, we have to step down from pure definitions of words and accept the common venacular. In America, today, "judge" no longer means to weigh the pros and cons of something but means to find fault. That's not the definition of the word, but it is how the word is understood by the majority of readers. In advertising, when the right word has the wrong connotation, we simply choose a better word or a word that is not negatively charged. It might not be a preferred way to communicate but it is what it is.

agirl -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 3:42:02 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: leatherzack For me, there is a big difference between having an opinion on someone's behavior and judging that person. The term "judging" is more definite to me. And to really judge someone, i think you have to know a lot about that person first, not just assume things (which is rather easy). I think the same way. I haven't found judgemental behaviour helpful or positive and don't like being around people that display it. * All druggies are arse-holes..... All down and outs are losers.......All children that wear hoodies are thugs.... Judging, on the other hand, is the act of forming an opinion.......... as far as I'm concerned, that is an ongoing, open-ended process. agirl

RiotGirl -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 5:30:20 AM)
I think the problem is not when we make judgements, but when we dont keep an open minded about it.

behindmirrors -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 5:55:33 AM)
I am a judgemental person, but in the sense that has been put forth already (much like the OP)- I look at what a person is like, and I form a strong opinion of them on account of that. I look at how they treat me and others, and at how they view themself as well. These things give you very telling information on where the road with that person will go, and helps me to decide if I want to walk with them, go my own way, or run the opposite direction as fast as I can. Judging people is learning to discern what you want and do not want to associate yourself with. If I hold a high opinion of someone, it's because of a good reason- and one that has taken careful thought. I'm not quick to trust, but I am quick to observe. Judgement takes time, but having that basis in observation is incredibly helpful. I think judgement is an incredibly helpful tool for everyone. Without having a basis of good judgement, we run into many problems- and, well, I'd rather be judicious and careful than end up miserable or hurt by another. behindmirrors. As a PS to the OP- I would love to get some more information on TIES...I live in Minneapolis, too, and it sounds great. I'll probably be sending you a message in a bit, here. I did check out the website, but I have a few more questions.

LotusSong -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 6:07:05 AM)
It's an opinion when they agree.. if they don't .. it's a judgment.

ElektraUkM -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 6:27:39 AM)
Well I suppose for me it depends on why one is doing the judging, on what basis, and whether or not you're keeping an open mind, asking questions, or being provisional about it. I don't see anything wrong with making an assessment that you don't want to give this person any more of your time... though you may end up losing out on experiences, other points of view or whatever. That's a personal decision. It's when judgment leads to criticism or outright condemnation that it irks, especially when the judgment was based on prejudice, lack of information or errors of ... err... judgment. And I suppose that's why the old 'judge not...' recommendation came into being...

truesub4u -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 6:31:40 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: LotusSong It's an opinion when they agree.. if they don't .. it's a judgment. That's how i've been seeing it. One is being judgmental.... when disagreeing with someone. As i've disagreed with a few on here in my 12 months on here. I've been acussed of beng judgemental because I don't agree.... because I oppose......because i've not tried something.....i've even gone so far as to agree to stop the flaming... to calm things down...even though my own opinions off line have not changed.... My judgement on things... people.... is what's kept me alive all these years....and I'll keep on having my judgemental thoughts.... no matter how others want to judge me for it...

emdoub -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 6:35:11 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: agirl I haven't found judgemental behaviour helpful or positive and don't like being around people that display it. * All druggies are arse-holes..... All down and outs are losers.......All children that wear hoodies are thugs.... Those phrases aren't judgemental so much as they are prejudicial - judging someone because of membership in a group, rather than on their individual merits. Now, I've gotta confess to being somewhat prejudiced, but I do strive to judge individuals as individuals - the groups they can be lumped into may make me wary, but I was taught at a young age to never be rude about my prejudices. Particularly racial prejudice - that was stressed quite a bit by my Grandfather. As he explained clearly, being rude to someone because of their racial background was unacceptable - after all, it's not like anyone would ever be anything but Irish by choice. [:D] Midnight Writer

Celeste43 -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 6:35:36 AM)
When someone says to me "don't be judgmental" what they mean is that they know they're doing something they shouldn't but want to get away with it without damaging people's opinions of them. Sorry, that doesn't wash. If you want to be known as a moral person, you have to act morally. Of course I'm judgmental, I don't want to be with people who lie, cheat, steal, are addicts etc so I judge what kind of people they are.

BrutalAntipathy -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 6:56:04 AM)
*I am impressed to see so many people admit that they are judgemental here. Everyone is, but most deny it.* Being the misanthrope that I am, I start with the assumption that everyone is absolute scum that is too stupid or ignorant to deserve anything other than my contempt, then allow myself to feel joy when the rare gem shines forth and breaks out of that judgement box.

CreativeDominant -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 7:11:53 AM)
Nicely stated, emdoub.[sm=applause.gif] I make judgments regarding people all the time. Sometimes, it helps to keep yhou alive or out of danger. I try to base my judgment based on a period of time learning their thoughts and observing their behaviors but with some people...those that are abrasive or rude or crude or act as if they think they are God/Goddess, etc....it comes rather quickly. When the judgment agrees with their thoughts, then I am "open-minded" and/or "very accepting". If it doesn't, then much the same as when my opinion on issues disagrees with someone, I am a narrow-minded/ non-compassionate/ idiotic/ pick your adjective type of person.

heartfeltsub -> RE: Judging others... (11/14/2006 7:28:07 AM)
To me there is a difference between making a judgement about an individual on whether or not we wish to continue dealing with that person, ie i don't want to spend my time with someone who will consistently lie to me and using that judgement to declare a person's future, ie a person who does X will never amount to anything. The one is a necessary skill to live successfully in this world, the other is outside the realm my expertise, i can't know how someone will turn out. That being said, there is a mentality that sprang up a few years ago, perpetuated by school systems, media and many other avenues that one is not allowed to do anything that would "hurt" the self-esteem of another by making any sort of judgement call about that person. That mindset is demonstrated by such ridiculous measures as telling teachers they can't mark papers in red because red hurts the student's feelings or can't fail a student because that would hurt their self image. This to me ends up just hurting the individual because in the real world, your boss, your co-workers are going to make judgements and base your salary, your continued employment, among other things on how you perform. And only by hearing how you are really performing can one make changes to improve oneself. So never giving someone an accurate picture of his/her perfomance based on set standards is counterproductive, and actually hurts far more than person's self esteem. So by not not "judging" a person, in my opinion, you are actually hurting them in the long run. * editted because i'm really tired and missed putting some words in that were needed.

Page: [1] 2 3 next > >>

Collarchat.com © 2025

Terms of Service

0.046875