Collarspace Discussion Forums


Home  Login  Search 

Michel Foucault on Punishment


View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
 
All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion >> Michel Foucault on Punishment Page: [1] 2   next >   >>
Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 7:53:44 AM   
RighteousBabe


Posts: 26
Joined: 6/25/2006
Status: offline 		I am not sure how many here are familar with the works of philosopher Michel Foucault....he certainly can be tough to read, but he has some brilliant writings on sexuality, discpline, punishment and power.  I came across this quote from Foucault and thought I would share it here.

“In its function, the power to punish is not essentially different from that of curing or educating.”
 
What are your thoughts on punishment (in the realm of BDSM) as a tool for educating and possibly even as a resource for curing/healing, as suggested above? 

Take care,
Tia
Profile   Post #: 1
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 7:59:53 AM   
mistoferin


Posts: 8284
Joined: 10/27/2004
Status: offline 		My personal opinion on punishment is that it is unnecessary in a relationship between mature adults who take responsibility for and are accountable for their own actions.

If you are interested in doing a search, we have had quite a number of threads regarding punishment...some within the last couple of weeks.

_____________________________

Peace and light,
~erin~

There are no victims here...only volunteers.

When you make a habit of playing on the tracks, you thereby forfeit the right to bitch when you get hit by a train.

"I did it! I admit it and I'm gonna do it again!"

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 2
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 8:05:54 AM   
RighteousBabe


Posts: 26
Joined: 6/25/2006
Status: offline 		Excellent...thank you mistoferin.  I have always been interested in the theories, research and history of punishment on a sociological level...that's how I discovered Mr. Foucault.   Since I have been exploring the BDSM realm in the last year or so, I'm looking at ways to link academic theories on punishment to the various views on punishment from folks who practice BDSM.  (I'm a bit of a research nut!)

Take care.

(in reply to mistoferin)
Profile   Post #: 3
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 8:10:09 AM   
velvetears


Posts: 2933
Joined: 6/19/2006
Status: offline 		Theres punishment and then theres discipline.  If the dynamic in wanted and works between the two consenting adults - who are we to judge.  i think those that like punishment (subs) like it because it releases them of the guilt they feel for having offended, disobeyed, etc their dom.  Some like the "game" and both really understand it as such. Then there are others (subs) who just use it as a way to manipulate the dom. 

i think if a dom is going to use punishment in his relationship with the sub he should do so very carefully and wisely.  Unless he likes dancing to her fiddle lol. 

Punishment means failure and thats a drag - why would any sub want to displease their dom to that point?  i know there have been many threads on punishment and i have read some of them.  i guess its on peoples minds a lot? 

If i were a dom and i had to punish my sub a lot i don't think i'd like my job very much


(in reply to mistoferin)
Profile   Post #: 4
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 8:19:29 AM   
SCORPIOXXX


Posts: 223
Joined: 11/6/2004
Status: offline 		I have read Foucalt as part of my Sociology classes... We should note that your quote is in the context of Punishment (that is: incarceration and all that goes with it) as beneficial to the State more than to the individual -- with the "cure and education" being no more than the fear of getting locked up again... As to how that applies to individual in a BDSM D/s dynamic, it depends on how Punishment is viewed: a pain slut may provoke punishment because she enjoys it (which is then no punishment at all); if un-enjoyable punishment is administerd (such as denial of "beating / sex / whatever", or being forced to watch W Bush speeches for hours) then of course the unwarranted behavior will change in all but the dumbest or most stubborn and obdurate people. The change may be educational (realization of action and its result), but as for the healing, this may apply only to the D/s dynamic rather than to the individual at fault... Of course, there is a huge difference between Foucalt's themes and a BDSM D/s dynamic: in the former, the object of punishment does not enter into it willingly and consentually (no one wants to go to jail, lol), whereas in the latter, the sub enters the relationship willingly and accepts the punishment in the same manner...

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 5
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 8:33:27 AM   
RighteousBabe


Posts: 26
Joined: 6/25/2006
Status: offline 		Very good points Scorpio...

Yes, Foucault's theory of punishment from his book "Discipline and Punish" indeed revolve around the contexts of incarceration and unwanted punishments.  Its true that Foucault's themes on the surface differ greatly from those of a BDSM dynamic, consent to punishment being a great factor.  Myself,  I am always interested in ways of finding links and common themes between various topics (even if they appear somewhat unrelated) and then brainstorm on ways to expand on those themes.  Its a quirk of mine...

So would you say that the concept of healing via punishment is more applicable in a D/s dynamic than it is in other circumstances such as in a criminological context?    BTW, I shudder to think of inflicting W's speeches for hours as a punishment technique...that's just plain cruel!!  :)

Thank you for sharing!

(edited to correct my spelling errors!)


< Message edited by RighteousBabe -- 7/30/2006 8:34:42 AM >

(in reply to SCORPIOXXX)
Profile   Post #: 6
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 9:10:49 AM   
Alumbrado


Posts: 5560
Status: offline 		Michael Tonry's works, including 'The Future of Imprisonment' make for some interesting follow up reading to Foucault, Bentham, et al.

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 7
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 11:24:37 AM   
DoctorDubious


Posts: 267
Joined: 6/24/2006
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: RighteousBabe

I am not sure how many here are familar with the works of philosopher Michel Foucault....he certainly can be tough to read, but he has some brilliant writings on sexuality, discpline, punishment and power.  I came across this quote from Foucault and thought I would share it here.

“In its function, the power to punish is not essentially different from that of curing or educating.”
 
What are your thoughts on punishment (in the realm of BDSM) as a tool for educating and possibly even as a resource for curing/healing, as suggested above? 

Take care,
Tia


Hi Tia.... and all....

Back when I was a young smartass,
instead of a friskysmartassoldbondagelovinggoatwithafloggerortwo

...I read Michel Fuckault, and even understood a word or two
(but not much more... cause the guy is intentionally obscure).

That shit up there is a tad out of context, but still fascinating....
as another poster pointed out.....
I think Fuckault does not understand BDSM,
but he really opened a lot of minds
about how POWER works in the real world,
and for that he will live a small corner of eternal thinkers...

************************************

But..... for me....
and in the context of a long-term, serious,
1 on 1 D/s relationship,
where her surrender is willing given ...
and I have earned the right to TAKE IT as I will....

--punishment is NOT primarily educational in nature
--punishement is NOT primarily "curing" in intent
--punishment is NOT even primarily about "training" my lover in obedience.
--punishment is NOT done for her "personal growth"

--punishment is just a raw expression of my power  ***(see note)
--punishment is done to give me the feelings I want ***
--punishment is sexual and feeds my kink,***
--punishment is pleasure for me, ***
--punishment can be done for the pleasure and amusement of my friends...***
--punishment can be done merely because I'm in the mood for dark pleasures ***

*** and it's OK by me if she also gets off on it,
but in a real power exchange,
her pleasure/kink/fun are incidental, secondary, and little-considered.
---- got it? 
Her needs and desires and training etc are incidental in a D/s relationship.****


DD, a bossy old goat who gets a kick from power

PS..... and before all you whiners flame me
for insensitivity towards the subs "oh-so-delicate-feelings"
go back and read the fricking context...
it's the first paragraph under the line of asterisks...

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 8
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 11:40:16 AM   
MissdeSade


Posts: 21
Joined: 4/24/2006
Status: offline 		Oh, how exciting to see a Foucault thread! I think punishment is essential to a certain type of slave or submissive training, but not essential to all D/S or M/S relationships. I think more Dominates actually use Foucault's theory of the panopticon more- that being watched is the greatest way to keep someone from misbehaving. The threat of eyes keep people in check. You should read Jacques Lacan if you like this stuff. 

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 9
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/30/2006 12:16:45 PM   
velvetears


Posts: 2933
Joined: 6/19/2006
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: DoctorDubious

But..... for me....
and in the context of a long-term, serious,
1 on 1 D/s relationship,
where her surrender is willing given ...
and I have earned the right to TAKE IT as I will....

--punishment is NOT primarily educational in nature
--punishement is NOT primarily "curing" in intent
--punishment is NOT even primarily about "training" my lover in obedience.
--punishment is NOT done for her "personal growth"

--punishment is just a raw expression of my power  ***(see note)
--punishment is done to give me the feelings I want ***
--punishment is sexual and feeds my kink,***
--punishment is pleasure for me, ***
--punishment can be done for the pleasure and amusement of my friends...***
--punishment can be done merely because I'm in the mood for dark pleasures ***

*** and it's OK by me if she also gets off on it,
but in a real power exchange,
her pleasure/kink/fun are incidental, secondary, and little-considered.
---- got it? 
Her needs and desires and training etc are incidental in a D/s relationship.****


At first when i read your post i thought you were confusing the terms punishment and sadism as the accepted definition of punishment is "A penalty imposed for wrongdoing: “The severity of the punishment must... be in keeping with the kind of obligation which has been violated” (Dictionary.com definition). 

But there is another definition which fits more in line with what you outlined here  - Rough handling; mistreatment: These old skis have taken a lot of punishment over the years. (Dictionary.com definition )- So i learned something new today

(in reply to DoctorDubious)
Profile   Post #: 10
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 12:05:29 AM   
songofeire


Posts: 40
Joined: 10/27/2005
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: DoctorDubious

************************************

But..... for me....
and in the context of a long-term, serious,
1 on 1 D/s relationship,
where her surrender is willing given ...
and I have earned the right to TAKE IT as I will....

--punishment is NOT primarily educational in nature
--punishement is NOT primarily "curing" in intent
--punishment is NOT even primarily about "training" my lover in obedience.
--punishment is NOT done for her "personal growth"

--punishment is just a raw expression of my power  ***(see note)
--punishment is done to give me the feelings I want ***
--punishment is sexual and feeds my kink,***
--punishment is pleasure for me, ***
--punishment can be done for the pleasure and amusement of my friends...***
--punishment can be done merely because I'm in the mood for dark pleasures ***

*** and it's OK by me if she also gets off on it,
but in a real power exchange,
her pleasure/kink/fun are incidental, secondary, and little-considered.
---- got it? 
Her needs and desires and training etc are incidental in a D/s relationship.****


DD, a bossy old goat who gets a kick from power

PS..... and before all you whiners flame me
for insensitivity towards the subs "oh-so-delicate-feelings"
go back and read the fricking context...
it's the first paragraph under the line of asterisks...


Ummmmm, yeah...
 (breathing hard)
What he said.
Is it me, or is it getting really warm in here?
 
Fanning self,
 
Rosemary
(whose admittedly incidental interests are piqued once again, or is it...still?)
 

(in reply to DoctorDubious)
Profile   Post #: 11
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 3:19:06 AM   
meatcleaver


Posts: 9030
Joined: 3/13/2006
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: RighteousBabe

I am not sure how many here are familar with the works of philosopher Michel Foucault....he certainly can be tough to read, but he has some brilliant writings on sexuality, discpline, punishment and power.  I came across this quote from Foucault and thought I would share it here.

“In its function, the power to punish is not essentially different from that of curing or educating.”
 
What are your thoughts on punishment (in the realm of BDSM) as a tool for educating and possibly even as a resource for curing/healing, as suggested above? 

Take care,
Tia


I've had several poems about him published, he was big when I was at college but he doesn't really stand up to scrutiny, he is more about self justification but an interesting figure, for being mainly wrong, I fear.

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 12
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 3:48:28 AM   
ExSteelAgain


Posts: 1803
Joined: 7/2/2006
From: Georgia
Status: offline 		Foucault also wrote about the power of sex in society. He felt it was real and strong, yet, not acknowledged. He was probably onto something there with the masses not understanding the power sex has, although most on this board would not be lumped with the unwashed in that respect.

_____________________________

You can paint a cinder block bright pastel pink, but it's still a cinder block. (By Me.)

(in reply to meatcleaver)
Profile   Post #: 13
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 4:42:45 AM   
meatcleaver


Posts: 9030
Joined: 3/13/2006
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: ExSteelAgain

Foucault also wrote about the power of sex in society. He felt it was real and strong, yet, not acknowledged. He was probably onto something there with the masses not understanding the power sex has, although most on this board would not be lumped with the unwashed in that respect.


His thoughts on power exchange are interesting though his writing is more about homosexual eperience. It's a while ago since I read him and he does differentiate between homosexual culture and hetrosexual culture and says they two experiences in power exchange are different. Though I'm not so sure how he knows, I wouldn't like to write on homosexual culture without experience. He doesn't convince me  but he does provoke ones thoughts about sexual power. Maybe it's time to reread him.

(in reply to ExSteelAgain)
Profile   Post #: 14
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 5:02:47 AM   
trixr4kids


Posts: 18
Joined: 7/27/2006
Status: offline 		My thoughts are if the Dom beats you in a previously stated punishment (ie. if you do such and such I will do such and such) no matter how extremely (short of permanent damage- not scars but real damage or health compramise) in a controlled way for your betterment than that is indeed punishing in love and guidance. If a Dom without prior stating a behavior will get you beat or beats you in anger no matter what your infraction was it's abuse.

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 15
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 8:14:43 AM   
songofeire


Posts: 40
Joined: 10/27/2005
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: trixr4kids

My thoughts are if the Dom beats you in a previously stated punishment (ie. if you do such and such I will do such and such) no matter how extremely (short of permanent damage- not scars but real damage or health compramise) in a controlled way for your betterment than that is indeed punishing in love and guidance. If a Dom without prior stating a behavior will get you beat or beats you in anger no matter what your infraction was it's abuse.


I think that if you are left with the impression that you have been abused, then you have. Your truth is your truth.
This is not to try to name *his* truth or *the* truth but so what?
You have to proceed from what is true for you, and make your decisions based on that.

just my truth,
Rosemary

(in reply to trixr4kids)
Profile   Post #: 16
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 8:43:13 AM   
RighteousBabe


Posts: 26
Joined: 6/25/2006
Status: offline 		Yes, Foucault is certainly a provactive writer when it comes to his themes on power and sexuality. I first read "Discipline & Punish" and "The History of Sexuality: Vol. 1" about 4 years ago in a wonderful course called "Introduction To Social Change".   I remember feeling quite initimidated by Foucault...but I had an excellent Sociology professor who really broke down his themes and concepts in a way I could relate to.  Now, each time I re-read Foucault, I find I pull out something new or am able to find new meaning in his words.  As I recall reading,  he was homosexual and he passed away from AIDS related complications in the 1980's. 

Thanks to all for the insightful comments!
Tia

quote:

ORIGINAL: meatcleaver


His thoughts on power exchange are interesting though his writing is more about homosexual eperience. It's a while ago since I read him and he does differentiate between homosexual culture and hetrosexual culture and says they two experiences in power exchange are different. Though I'm not so sure how he knows, I wouldn't like to write on homosexual culture without experience. He doesn't convince me  but he does provoke ones thoughts about sexual power. Maybe it's time to reread him.


(in reply to meatcleaver)
Profile   Post #: 17
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 10:03:24 AM   
thetammyjo


Posts: 6322
Joined: 9/8/2005
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: RighteousBabe

I am not sure how many here are familar with the works of philosopher Michel Foucault....he certainly can be tough to read, but he has some brilliant writings on sexuality, discpline, punishment and power. I came across this quote from Foucault and thought I would share it here.

“In its function, the power to punish is not essentially different from that of curing or educating.”

What are your thoughts on punishment (in the realm of BDSM) as a tool for educating and possibly even as a resource for curing/healing, as suggested above?

Take care,
Tia


That is how I view punishment -- its a means to change behavior and attitude, one way to teach. This is the reason that I do not have standard punishments but make them suit the person and the issue. It is also a reason I use practice or redoing something rather than any punishment -- doing something over and over can help you learn to do it better.

I believe it is the 5 times rule in pedagogy -- you need to go over the material at least five times to learn it.

_____________________________

Love, Peace, Hugs, Kisses, Whips & Chains,

TammyJo

Check out my website at http://www.thetammyjo.com Or www.tammyjoeckhart.com

And my LJ where I post fiction in progress if you "friend" me at http://thetammyjo.livejournal.com/

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 18
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 10:56:14 AM   
cloudboy


Posts: 7306
Joined: 12/14/2005
Status: offline
In the enlightened sense, “the power to punish is not essentially different from that of curing or educating,” is truthy. In the sadistic, brutalization sense, it is falsey.

Also, "punishment" in the BDSM context is a rather elastic term. Some might consider being paddled or caned "play," whereas I would not. For me that would either be "work" or punishment. I'm not sure I would classify the outcome of such as "curing" or "educating", as much as I would see it as a sacrificial taking and unification between top and bottom.


(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 19
RE: Michel Foucault on Punishment - 7/31/2006 5:39:12 PM   
happypervert


Posts: 2203
Joined: 5/11/2004
From: Scranton, PA
Status: offline
quote:

the power to punish is not essentially different from that of curing or educating

What I find interesting about this quote is that he compares the power to punish to curing and educating. He could have chosen to be gramatically consistent and say that punishing is not essentially different, but that changes the meaning to an exercise of that power.

So, I can agree with that -- having the power is enough; one doesn't have to use it. The power can also be used in more constructive ways as TammyJo suggests.

< Message edited by happypervert -- 7/31/2006 5:40:26 PM >

(in reply to RighteousBabe)
Profile   Post #: 20
Page:   [1] 2   next >   >>
All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion >> Michel Foucault on Punishment Page: [1] 2   next >   >>
Jump to:





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy

0.078