The scope of our society (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


Termyn8or -> The scope of our society (11/13/2009 11:59:57 PM)

To preface I must say this is hypothetical, but possible.

For one, nobody really knows what has happened throughout the history of this planet. I now cite the old movie "The Gods Must Be Crazy". A guy throws a Coke bottle over a hill or something and some primitive tribe finds it. Just about the whole movie is about those primitives trying to figure out what this this is and what it's for.

Now in history some have become explorers, to the ends of the Earth if they could, and have discovered tribes of peoples in isolated areas who have absolutely no idea of the existence of the technicological age or anything alse. Still living the old way. Completely oblivious to the megopolis' around them, even if they are nearby. They basically mind their own business and live their own lives. Explorers go out and find things, people, new lands and who knows what, because they want to . Others just don't want to.

What we have reaped in the scope of human knowledge is vast, but still not yet complete, to disagree would be illogical. So now, since we, without even trying to hide, were not discovered by primitives, how can we logically say that there are not more advanced people on the planet, but with the technology to remain hidden if they wish ?

I am not asserting that such people exist, I am proposing it as a topic for discussion. If for example, you were born into said society, in which your intelligence is ten times what we consider the norm, why would you bother to make contact with us ? Likewise with extraterrestrials, but that is not the subject here.

If you were able to live far far under the deepest sea, completely away from most of the world. Self sufficient, with artificial or gathered sunlight, have lushious gardens and all of your family and friends with you, why would you bother with a world like our's ? Immune to wars and even a nuclear holocaust, would you seek the surface ?

As far as I know, we haven't even been to the very bottom of Lake Superior, let alone the oceans. If they developed small scale fusion technology they could easily live under the Antarctic ice if they chose. We haven't seen every inch of that.

You can say there would be a thermal signature and yes that might be true. But if enough energy is available the heat can be sent further underground where it will never be detected. Just like the stealth bomber shoots all the heat upwards in spite of the fact the the thrust is downward. Something like that.

They could even have spaceships, and run undetected using more advanced technology just like old RADAR jammers. Not really old ones, the first ones just made noise, later versions actually convert and analyze the "blip" and adjust frequency and phase to match, thus making an object invisible to the RADAR scan. The noise reducing headphones worn on some helicopters work in a similar manner, except it's venue is that of the sonic rather than the electromagnetic.

I know this is possible, and if started studying science as a pre teen you might as well. All of physics is related, except nuclear. Physics starts with a lever, but that same principle applies to hydraulics, electronics and so forth. Pneumatics is a bit of a different animal but it is only a bit more complex. But a small hydaulic piston feeding a larger one is the same as a lever, and also the same as an impedance matching, or any transformer. Can anyone say for sure that more technology than we have discovered does not exist ? Can anyone say that we are the preeminant "human race" or even species of the world ?

You can't. You can't disprove the existence of anything, at least to anyone with a scientific mind. If you go really far fetched they might think 'not likely', but they will never accept disproof. Disproof is simply not in some people's mental vocabulary. Some of them are the smartest people on this planet----- that we know of.

We tend to go to the top of the heap only to have the heap fall down. We go to the top of the hill only to get knocked down. We go to the top of the food chain only to be eaten by a wild animal. We keep getting knocked down time and time again yet seem to maintain that we are all of the above, and then some. To claim this we would have to be omnipresent and pretty much omnipotent. Therefore to claim this we would be decalring ourselves Gods.

Think of it, to live in a secret society in which space travel is common, but shielding it from the regualar biomass is no sweat. First of all if you want to take the spaceship out somewhere, do it at night, first of all you aren't usually going to the sun, so you are already pointed in the right direction. And then it is night, so forget those lights and shit like in the movies. After that all you have to do is shield yourself from a vastly inferior technology.

And it would be vastly inferior as well, because to have a spaceship have any use at all you either need a long lifespan, greater than light speeds (which I think are possible) or something it takes to get to the nearest star system. It is a bit far.

I am talking about a whole different culture, one that has improved itself drastically, say over the millenia. Perhaps all the religious folklore and that is just them giving it a try, trying to help us. Perhaps they have given up ? Perhaps they have just decided to recuse themselves from this game of life we have been playing for millenia. Perhaps they wanted no part of it. With all the resorces we waste on war, they turn their minds to science and perhaps even eugenics. They don't waste their time.

If such a society exists it would go far to explain the supposed miracles and whatever else purported to have happened in the past. I try to figure things out. I don't let anyone really put thoughts into my mind, and it is a damnsight harder to get them out. For example, 'Jesus walked on the water', OK, was he the first to swim and taught others ? I doubt that, it was a bit flippant, but one Bible translator I heard of said "According to this text, Jesus could've been a mushroom with psycodelic effects". He was promptly dismissed. Was what he said true ? He was a linguist, and called em as he sawem. He was dismissed and my only conclusion is that we are being manipulated when it comes to this subject.

When I was about seven I read a book called "Creation Or Evolution". It took me all of five seconds to figure that one out. We define days within the universal parameters, the Earth rotates and all that, so away from the sun is night and towards the sun is day. Simple concept really. But God created the Earth in a day ? Well he defined days back then, not us. He could've sat on his ass for millenia and called it a day when he was good and damn ready. These issues are all resolved in my mind. A "higher power" may have made it happen, but like Henry Ford created cars.

The only creations attributable to humanity are in the realm of art. Even so, they so not appear out of thin air. Music is created largely out of language, visual art is created out of a canvass and paint or ink, or a rock and a hammer and chisel, or even a twig and a whittler's knife.

So to believe in creation is to believe that we were a concept of some vast mind, of some higher power's imagination. That I can actually understand. But the world went for so long with the assumption that it only happened once, even on this planet. How can anyone assert that ?

The omnipresent and omnipotent are welcome to try.

T




lally2 -> RE: The scope of our society (11/14/2009 2:55:55 AM)

oh wow, i love the idea - though it isnt a new one really. if you read CSLewis and his Narnia books, Alice in Wonderland, but they are more along the lines of shamanic travel to the underworld or middle world. but even Tolkein with his Middle Earth and forests full of elves explores the possibilities of parrallel dimensions, veils that hide other worlds that coexist but in a different way.

Stephen Hawkin is a recent proponent that there are infact no less than 11 parrallel dimensions alongside ours.

i am pagan and so my core belief system is very much tied up with earth as a supporter of much more than we can see or touch or hear and is largely based around instinct and the endless possiblities that Life in its constant dedication to keep on growing, changing and evolving may very well have all sorts of things that science is trying to fathom but cant - and since science is the religion of the day - people wait for science to speak before they open their minds to unquantifiable possibilities.

which is fine, because being a selfish witch i like to keep the woods to myself anyway. [:)]




Termyn8or -> RE: The scope of our society (11/14/2009 4:36:41 AM)

Hawkins is good, but I believe there are an infinite number of dimensions.

More later, need some sleep.

T




pahunkboy -> RE: The scope of our society (11/14/2009 8:43:32 AM)

I would not want to go to a primitive life.   I like hot water- light and todays conveniences.

As to going to a more advanced life-  at one time I thought I would want to.  But I doubt it anymore.

Just about any innovation we enjoy has come due to WAR.   We kill people.  We learn to kill efficiently--  those inventions start off for war then later end up as modern niceties to life.

This means that for the next round of neat stuff- we will see alot of killing first.

Everything is so controlled.   What "they" want to do.  At least today there is a few things that they can not force us to do. 

So enjoy that.

We live in a unique time in history.  A point which is pivotal and will never occur again.  We are the pioneers of the teck age.

But- when they all went west in covered buggies and it took many months- you did not need a license- insurance- inpection- and smog check.  

The industrial revolution was all fun too at first until Lake Erie caught on fire.    The teck thing started out neato- and the day where a machine controls the human is with in sight.

So- go to the future?   Hell no.




SL4V3M4YB3 -> RE: The scope of our society (11/14/2009 4:15:55 PM)

Interesting concept but if they don't interact with us and can conceal themselves from us then for all intents and purpose they don't exist.

The question of why an advanced society would study a less advanced one is easily answered by the fascination we have with history and our origins. Overtime what you forget is where it started from and no matter how advanced you become there is always the risk you'll lose touch with your heritage or the reasons you came about; reasons that could be alien to your current concept of existence.




Termyn8or -> RE: The scope of our society (11/15/2009 11:13:01 AM)

"Interesting concept but if they don't interact with us and can conceal themselves from us then for all intents and purpose they don't exist. "

Interesting. This is Sunday and I am feeling a bit froggy.

So if malevolent aliens showed up and started blowing up the planet, there might be a beam comes from Antarctica that destroys them. We would then know of their existence.

Imagine if this were true. Imagine what the government would do. First of all I'd like to see any fucking President sit down in his office with someone from a race that would obliterate his country with the push of a button. And to know that this "danger" is right here on Earth. To know that there is not a fucking thing even our best mercenaries could do about it.

Practical invisibility does not require selective bending of light ray like in a Star Trek "cloaking device", it is a matter of blending in with the surroundings. They could be among us at certain times, and we would have no idea. I think it would be a simple matter. I said Antarctica because it is easily understood, but there are many areas of the world they could live in peace.

Like with Star Trek, they might have a non-interference directive. Even I have ideas that I won't even try to patant because that makes them public knowledge. I could turn a fusion reactor into a huge weapon, even a mocrowave into a smaller one. In fact maybe the MASER would start the fusion reaction. Alot of people have the stuff with which to do so in their own basements but have no clue how to do it. I do.  Not the fusion reactor, the weapon made from a microwave.

Even on Star Trek, sometimes they would talk to the leaders of some far off civilisation, but their exisence was known to few. And these leaders were not always the government. What if they came and contacted me ? Am I fit to represtent my race or species ? What kind of excuse would I give for our behavior ? "They are young", actually referring to the old as well. It is not only the US that is young, I think the human race is young. We have so many issues that should not be issues it is ridiculous. With all of their technology, this is the most important milestone they have passed and we have not. Abortion, to them it is no different than a lion eating some of her cubs because they just don't smell right. Our wars themselves could be a spectator sport in their venue, maybe quite popular. They would of course always be watching for something we may do to the planetwide environment that might hurt them in some way. Other than that they will not interfere with us primitives.

Put reality aside for a fw minutes and imagine. It is an interesting concept I think, something to muse about at the very least.

But setting aside myself for the moment, what would I do if I were one of them. I enjoy comfort, security and privacy to a degree none of us have ever experienced. I have peace. The world is all wrong but I am right, and the primitives can go to hell in a handbasket for all I care. We will be alright. In this society human beings are regarded as an endangered species. And their major natural predator is themselves. Can we call ourselves human without this trait ? Well that is a philosophical question posed to our third graders. They might walk among us at times, but very rarely. Why would they ? What could they possibly gain from exposure to us ?

Perhaps this is a stab at introspection, not only of myself but of the human race by proxy. What would impel a superior being to contact us, whether extraterrestrial or not ? What would be gained ? What do we have to offer anyone ? As we know it, the human race of which we are part has very little to offer in ideology, morality, anything. In reality you can trust us better as enemies than friends, and everyone knows it. We would be seen as animals by a truly superior race or species. Perhaps worse.

More later.

T




SL4V3M4YB3 -> RE: The scope of our society (11/15/2009 12:09:08 PM)

Take this a step further and perhaps argue that those that hear voices in their heads are the only people that can communicate with this advanced race. It is a kind of dangerous speculation perhaps they interact with and learn from those they know the rest of us will give no credibility to. Perhaps we are some kind of food source, perhaps we could live longer but this alternative race finds a way to end our lives early so that when we are buried at 80 and they can then feed off our corpses. perhaps they will rise up against us if we continue to switch to cremation over burial.

There are many ideas where we could be totally oblivious to a controlling alien race on this earth, your imagination is only the limit really.




lally2 -> RE: The scope of our society (11/16/2009 7:17:04 AM)

why oh (freaking) why do 'they' have to be violent - because we are i suppose. frankly if i was them id stay the hell away too.

War of the Worlds, et al, have all played their part in convincing us that aliens are treacherous monsters.

but step away from all of that Hollywood hooha for a moment and reflect for a moment on the premis of this planet. the entire premis of this planet is Life, pure and simple. the arrogance of man assumes that the planet is his creation, that all of his politics, wars and nonsense are a true reflection of the planet as a whole. not so, not atall so.

the true reflection of this planet is Life. without that premis this planet would curl up and die. the energy that sparked life onto this spinning rock continues and will always continue long after we have gone. i find that so reassuring.

romantically enough, we can all step into a parrallel dimension, each time we sit on a beach, walk in a wood, sit on a hill, climb a mountain, soak in the peace and wonder that draws us to these places and heals us. is it impossible to imagine that the energies and forces that we tap into each time we visit nature and sit quietly for a while arent actually trying to reach out to us and remind us that each time we honour materialism, war and acquisition we are being pushed further and further away from the very thing we are all part of.... LIFE. not war, not destruction.

ok, im pagan, so this is my belief structure anyway.

but i do believe that we can and do tap into these parrallel dimensions and we do feel them, subliminally perhaps. but when we get back from our holiday at the seaside or camping in the fields we return refreshed, peaceful and restored. some of us, people like me, take this a little further. and i want to share something really wonderful right now and i dont give a hoot how mad you think i am. but the other night i was meditating peacefully and i heard a mans voice in my right ear ask me this:.....

'will you fly around the moon with me' - what evil monstrous creatures do you suppose could come up with something so romantically beautiful. none that i can think of.

we truely need to open ourselves up to the possibilities that science can never prove.

the Dalai Lamma wrote once that the religion of today is science. we believe in what the scientists can prove. but if any one of us asked one of those scientists a personal question on morality they would not be able to answer us, not without prejudice - our morality and our emotions go way beyond anything we can fully explain and these two things connect us more emphatically to nature and animals and to each other than anything science can prove.

we have grown up massively since the all time arrogant quote of the last centuary was coined - that if a tree fell down in the forest would it make a sound if noone was there to hear it. thankfully we have moved on since that was lauded profound and i take huge solace from the amount that is being done to protect and conserve this amazing planet of ours. but there is so much we dont understand and we will never fathom.

this planet,the universe has more mystery in it than we can possibly imagine and just its simple faith in LIFE makes what we get up to on a collective basis pretty bloody sad really.

steps off soap box. [:D]





mnottertail -> RE: The scope of our society (11/16/2009 7:20:54 AM)

we can be sure of one thing is there is an intelligent life out there, they have just as strong an innate drive to thrive and survive as we do, and will be wary of unknown but similar species intentions.

99 times out of 100 it aint gonna turn out pretty, should we meet up.

Ron




BrokenSaint -> RE: The scope of our society (11/16/2009 1:08:58 PM)

We can also be sure of something else. If something lives. It can die. If it's carbon based there's a 99 % chance that hitting it with things, will be what causes it to die.

I find that comforting.




xssve -> RE: The scope of our society (11/16/2009 1:39:46 PM)

quote:

What we have reaped in the scope of human knowledge is vast, but still not yet complete, to disagree would be illogical. So now, since we, without even trying to hide, were not discovered by primitives, how can we logically say that there are not more advanced people on the planet, but with the technology to remain hidden if they wish ?
There are - they're called CollarMeites. [sm=banana.gif]




mnottertail -> RE: The scope of our society (11/16/2009 1:44:56 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: BrokenSaint

We can also be sure of something else. If something lives. It can die. If it's carbon based there's a 99 % chance that hitting it with things, will be what causes it to die.

I find that comforting.




I won't find that comforting until we actually have light sabers.

Ron




Page: [1]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
2.734375E-02