rulemylife
Posts: 14614
Joined: 8/23/2004 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: hizgeorgiapeach Rule, while I appreciate sarcasm as much (if not more) than most - I wasn't simply being pithy. I am a pilot myself. I know how pilots are trained, having gone through it myself. I am quite aware, as a pilot, that it's NOT THAT FRIGGIN HARD for someone who is Trained - which the article admitted the guy IS - to go from one type to another type of aircraft. If the guy were completely untrained, were not certificated by the FAA as a pilot - my attitude about his "accomplishment" would be significantly different. Yes, different types of aircraft each have their own quirks, but the guy who landed it - a Certificated Pilot - is NOT the same as someone who is completely NOT Certificated having achieved the same thing. While the KingAire is a considerably larger plane than what most SELs (and even a lot of non-commercial MELs) are used to, it's still relies on Props, which is something that we get used to in primary training. And even the cockpit of a Boeing '47 isn't set up That differently than the cockpit of a Piper Cherokee, for a Certificated Pilot to be completely lost and confounded when facing the new instrument panel. The basic instrumentation is the same, although there's a helluva lot more of it, and certain items are located in pretty much an identical position regardless of which aircraft you're sitting in. Would I expect someone that had absolutely Zero training to be thrown for a bit of a loop? Absolutely. Would I expect them to panic, have no clue where to look for things like the standard pre-landing checklists, know which instrument was what, and be lauded as someone who achieved something completely out of their league. Again, Absolutely. But frankly, I expect a Lot More than that from those whom I happen to share the skies with as a Trained, Certificated Pilot who has been tested by the FAA. I expect a lot more compitance, and the ability to adapt to difficulties in flight that an untrained person wouldn't be capable of coping with. So no - I'm not impressed that he safely landed a plane that he's not type certed for, and will remain unimpressed with a feat that any trained pilot should be capable of accomplishing in an emergency situation of the specific sort he was faced with. While I'm duly impressed, me too. And to expect a private pilot who has only flown single-engine to manage a King-Air "competently" is a ridiculous assumption. He did very well just to get it on the ground.
|